Introduction
The Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (TCPA 1990) defines 'development' as covering building, engineering, mining operations, or any material change in the use of land or buildings. Understanding the activities that fall outside this definition is important within planning law. This examination focuses on matters that do not constitute development, detailing statutory exemptions and their implications for property transactions under UK law.
The Legal Framework of 'Development'
Under Section 55(1) of the TCPA 1990, 'development' includes a wide range of activities, such as building, engineering, mining operations, and significant changes in the use of land or buildings. However, certain activities are explicitly excluded from this definition. Identifying these exclusions is significant, as they impact whether planning permission is required for specific actions.
Statutory Exemptions
Section 55(2) of the TCPA 1990 specifies activities that are not considered 'development':
- Internal alterations to buildings
- Use of land or buildings within the curtilage of a dwellinghouse for purposes incidental to its use as such
- Changes in use within the same use class
- Certain changes of use prescribed by development orders
Understanding these exemptions helps in effectively managing planning requirements.
Activities That Do Not Constitute Development
Let's look into the activities exempt from the development definition and consider their practical implications.
1. Internal Alterations
Alterations confined entirely within a building's interior, which do not affect its external appearance or footprint, are not classified as development. Such changes typically include:
- Redesigning internal layouts
- Installing new fixtures and fittings
- Renovating existing rooms
While planning permission isn't required for these internal works, compliance with building regulations remains necessary to ensure safety standards are met.
Example: A homeowner decides to transform an unused attic into a home office. Since the alterations are internal and do not modify the building's exterior, planning permission is generally unnecessary. However, compliance with building regulations for structural integrity and fire safety is still mandatory.
2. Incidental Uses Within the Curtilage of a Dwellinghouse
Activities within the grounds of a dwellinghouse that are incidental to its enjoyment as a residence are exempt from being considered development. This category encompasses:
- Erecting a garden shed
- Setting up a children's play area
- Installing a domestic greenhouse
These uses should remain subordinate to the main residential purpose of the property.
Example: If a family installs a small greenhouse in their garden to grow vegetables for personal use, this is incidental to the dwelling's enjoyment and does not require planning permission.
3. Changes Within the Same Use Class
Under the Town and Country Planning (Use Classes) Order 1987 (as amended), land and buildings are grouped into various use classes. Changing the use of a building or land to another use within the same class is not considered development. Examples include:
- Converting a clothing store to a bookstore within Class E
- Changing a restaurant to a café, provided they fall within the same use class
Recent amendments have broadened these classes, allowing for greater flexibility.
Example: An office space (Class E) is repurposed as a retail shop (also Class E). Since both uses fall under the same class, planning permission is not required for this change.
4. Changes of Use Prescribed by Development Orders
Some changes of use between different classes are permitted under the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) Order 2015 (GPDO 2015). These are known as permitted development rights and include:
- Changing offices (Class E) to residential use (Class C3)
- Converting agricultural buildings to dwellinghouses
While these changes are permitted, they often require a prior approval process with the local planning authority to address specific impacts, such as transport or flooding.
Example: A farmer wishes to convert an old barn into a residential dwelling. Under Class Q of the GPDO 2015, this change is permitted development, subject to prior approval regarding matters like noise, contamination, and design.
Special Considerations: Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas
Listed Buildings
For buildings designated as 'listed' due to their historical or architectural significance, even internal alterations may require listed building consent. This is to preserve the character and integrity of these important structures.
Example: Altering the interior of a Grade II listed cottage by installing modern fixtures might necessitate listed building consent, ensuring that the changes do not adversely affect the building's special interest.
Conservation Areas
Properties located within conservation areas are subject to additional planning controls to protect the area's character and appearance. This means that some permitted development rights are restricted or removed.
Example: Erecting a small extension that would normally be permitted development may require full planning permission if the property is in a conservation area. The local planning authority will assess the proposal's impact on the area's character before granting permission.
Practical Implications for Property Transactions
Understanding what does not constitute development has significant implications in property transactions:
-
Due Diligence: Buyers and solicitors must verify that any existing alterations or uses comply with planning laws. Unauthorised developments can lead to enforcement action or affect property value.
-
Risk Assessment: Identifying activities that are exempt assists in assessing potential risks. For instance, if previous owners made changes that didn't require planning permission, it reduces the likelihood of future legal issues.
-
Development Potential: Knowing which changes are permitted without planning permission can make a property more attractive by highlighting its development possibilities.
-
Negotiations and Contracts: Awareness of planning exemptions assists in drafting contracts with appropriate warranties and representations regarding compliance with planning regulations.
Example: Before purchasing a property, a solicitor confirms that a garage conversion was an incidental use within the curtilage of the dwellinghouse and did not require planning permission. This reassurance facilitates the transaction and mitigates future risks.
Case Study: Permitted Development Rights and Local Restrictions
Consider a scenario where Ms. Patel plans to add a modest rear extension to her semi-detached house. Under normal circumstances, this extension would be permitted development under the GPDO 2015. However, she discovers that her local authority has an Article 4 Direction in place, which removes certain permitted development rights in her area.
Analysis:
-
Permitted Development Assessment: The proposed extension fits within the parameters of permitted development rights outlined in Class A of Part 1 of Schedule 2 of the GPDO 2015.
-
Article 4 Direction Impact: The local Article 4 Direction restricts these rights, meaning permitted development does not apply in this case.
-
Requirement for Planning Permission: Ms. Patel must apply for full planning permission for her extension, despite it typically being permitted development.
This example illustrates the importance of checking local planning policies and understanding how they may override general exemptions.
Examples of Use Class Transitions in Practice
Let's examine a business owner who wants to convert a small retail shop (Class E) into a café (also Class E).
Considerations:
-
Same Use Class Transition: Changing from a retail shop to a café falls within the same use class, so it is not considered development, and planning permission is not required.
-
Other Regulations: Despite not needing planning permission, the owner must comply with other regulations, such as building regulations, licensing laws, and environmental health requirements.
-
Conditions and Covenants: The owner should check for any planning conditions or restrictive covenants that might prohibit such a change of use.
By understanding these details, property professionals can facilitate smoother transactions and advise clients more effectively.
Conclusion
The complexity of what does not constitute development under UK planning law demands careful attention. Understanding these exemptions is indispensable for handling property transactions and ensuring compliance. This analysis has explored the key statutory exclusions outlined in the TCPA 1990 and the GPDO 2015, along with their practical applications and limitations.
The most perplexing concept involves the interplay between permitted development rights and local planning controls, such as Article 4 Directions. These local measures can restrict or remove permitted development rights, necessitating full planning permission where it might not typically be required.
Key technical principles include the recognition of internal alterations, incidental uses within the curtilage of a dwellinghouse, and changes within the same use class as activities not constituting development. Additionally, certain changes of use are prescribed by development orders, allowing for flexibility in property use without the need for planning permission.
These concepts interact in various ways. For example, while a homeowner might rely on permitted development rights to make alterations, local restrictions or the listed status of a building can override these rights. Similarly, changes within the same use class are generally permissible, but associated conditions or covenants may impose additional requirements.
Specific requirements must be observed to ensure compliance:
-
Verify Local Planning Policies: Always check for Article 4 Directions or conservation area designations that may affect permitted development rights.
-
Assess Listed Building Status: Determine whether the property is listed, as this significantly impacts what alterations are allowed without consent.
-
Review Use Class Regulations: Understand the current use class of a property and whether the intended change falls within the same class or is permitted under development orders.
-
Compliance with Building Regulations: Even when planning permission is not required, building regulations still apply to ensure safety and standards.
In conclusion, a thorough understanding of matters not constituting development improves the ability to manage property transactions effectively. By recognizing statutory exemptions, interpreting local policies, and applying this knowledge to real-world scenarios, professionals can manage the complexities of planning law with confidence.
